Joseph Biggs, a onetime Proud Boys lieutenant, was sentenced to 17 years for seditious conspiracy in the Jan. 6 riot.

Thursday, August 31, 2023 1:06 PM ET

The penalty for Mr. Biggs is the second longest so far in more than 1,100 criminal cases stemming from the Capitol attack.

Two leaders of the Proud Boys were sentenced to lengthy prison terms on Thursday for their roles in the assault on the Capitol on Jan. 6, 2021, with a top lieutenant in the far-right group, Joseph Biggs, given 17 years, and another key figure in the attack, Zachary Rehl, getting 15 years.

Mr. Biggs’s sentence following his conviction in the spring on charges of seditious conspiracy was one of the stiffest penalties issued so far in more than 1,100 criminal cases stemming from the Capitol attack and among only a handful to have been legally labeled an act of terrorism.

It was just over half of the 33 years the government had requested and just shy of the 18-year term given in May to Stewart Rhodes, the leader of another far-right group, the Oath Keepers militia, who was also found guilty of sedition in connection with the attack on the Capitol by a pro-Trump mob.

The sentences, handed down by Judge Timothy J. Kelly in Federal District Court in Washington, kicked off a series of hearings scheduled for this week and next at which punishment will be meted out against the former chairman of the Proud Boys, Enrique Tarrio, and two other members of the group who were convicted of sedition and other serious crimes at a landmark conspiracy trial this spring.

Hours after sentencing Mr. Biggs, Judge Kelly imposed a 15-year sentence on Mr. Rehl, who had also been convicted on sedition charges. Prosecutors had sought a 30-year term for Mr. Rehl.

The Proud Boys — who had been fighting on the streets since 2017 for a range of far-right causes — became a central focus of the F.B.I.’s investigation into Jan. 6 within days of the Capitol attack.

Aside from Mr. Biggs and his co-defendants in the sedition case — Mr. Tarrio, Mr. Rehl, Ethan Nordean and Dominic Pezzola — more than 20 other members of the group from chapters ranging from New York to Hawaii were ultimately charged in separate indictments.

The Justice Department’s prosecutions of the Proud Boys all but decapitated the group’s national leadership, which was formally disbanded after the Capitol attack, and mostly put an end to its involvement in large-scale — often violent — pro-Trump rallies in cities across the country.

But as arrests began after Jan. 6, Mr. Tarrio and his circle of lieutenants started an effort to have their followers become involved in right-wing politics in different ways. For some, that meant running for local offices or positions in county Republican organizations. For others, it meant taking part in smaller-scale protests at school boards or against L.G.B.T.Q. events.

For Mr. Biggs, the sentence effectively ended an unusual career that included a stint as a combat soldier, a job as a roving correspondent for the conspiracy theory website Infowars and a leadership role in the Proud Boys at a moment when the far-right group was thrust from the fringes of national politics and into the center of the 2020 election for their backing of President Donald J. Trump.

Mr. Biggs, one of Mr. Tarrio’s closest confidants, helped run the Proud Boys when Mr. Trump famously called out the organization during a presidential debate against Joseph R. Biden Jr., telling its members to “stand back and stand by.”

A lesser known figure, Mr. Rehl — the son and grandson of police officers in Philadelphia — ran that city’s chapter of the Proud Boys. He served as what prosecutors called a “managing supervisor” of the conspiracy to disrupt the certification of Mr. Trump’s defeat that was taking place inside the Capitol on Jan. 6

Mr. Rehl marched with Mr. Biggs that day at the head of a crowd of nearly 200 Proud Boys from the Washington Monument to the Capitol and ultimately shot a canister of chemical spray at officers protecting the building. During the trial, he also lied about the attack, saying he had never assaulted anyone, Judge Kelly found.

Racked by sobs, Mr. Rehl apologized to his friends and family — and even the prosecution team — telling Judge Kelly he believed the “lies about the election” spread by politicians.

“I’m done peddling lies for other people who don’t care about me,” he said.

Mr. Biggs also wept when he addressed the court, saying that he had turned to drinking — a favorite Proud Boy pastime — after coming back from combat overseas and that the only group he wanted to be affiliated with these days is “my daughter’s P.T.A.”

“I know that I messed up that day,” he said, “but I’m not a terrorist.”

Judge Kelly in turn told Mr. Biggs that the attack on the Capitol, which he had helped to instigate, was a “national disgrace.”

“What happened on Jan. 6 harmed an important American custom,” Judge Kelly said. “That day broke our tradition of peacefully transferring power, which is among the most precious things we had as Americans. Notice I said ‘had’ — we don’t have it anymore.”

The Proud Boys’ sedition trial, which lasted more than three months, was one of the most significant criminal proceedings to have emerged from the Capitol attack. Prosecutors portrayed the group under the command of Mr. Biggs and Mr. Tarrio as some of the most violent people in the enormous pro-Trump mob that stormed the building, with dozens of its members playing decisive roles in breaching barricades and assaulting the police.

In court papers filed this month, prosecutors described Mr. Biggs as “a vocal leader” of the Proud Boys and an “influential proponent of the group’s shift toward political violence,” noting that within days of Mr. Trump’s election loss he had declared that the country could face “civil war.”

Shortly after Mr. Trump posted a message on Twitter, summoning his followers to what he predicted would be a “wild” protest in Washington on Jan. 6, Mr. Biggs wrote to Mr. Tarrio, encouraging him to “get radical and get real men” to answer Mr. Trump’s call to action.

On Jan. 6 itself, Mr. Biggs took part in an episode outside the Capitol that was widely seen as a tipping point in the riot. He had a private conversation with a man in the crowd, Ryan Samsel, after which Mr. Samsel approached a barricade and confronted the police, resulting in the first breach of the Capitol’s security perimeter.

After serving eight years in the Army, some as a noncommissioned officer in combat tours of Iraq, Mr. Biggs “appreciated the tactical advantage that his force had that day, and he understood the significance of his actions against his own government,” prosecutors said.

Moreover, they noted, Mr. Biggs recorded a podcast after the riot in which he declared that the attack on the Capitol was “a warning shot to the government.”

Mr. Biggs’s contacts in the world of right-wing politics were never restricted solely to the Proud Boys. Like Mr. Tarrio, he has long had ties to Roger J. Stone Jr., one of Mr. Trump’s political advisers. He has also been involved at the edges of far-right disinformation campaigns like the Pizzagate conspiracy theory, which falsely held that top Democrats like Hillary Clinton ran a child sex trafficking operation from the basement of a Washington pizzeria.

While working at Infowars for its proprietor, the conspiracy theorist Alex Jones, Mr. Biggs often covered the far-right militia movement. In 2014, for example, he followed members of the Oath Keepers to Ferguson, Mo., as the group deployed — in its own words — to protect local businesses against unrest that stemmed from a failure to bring charges against a local police officer who had killed a Black man, Michael Brown.

During the sedition trial, prosecutors played a brief video from Jan. 6 in which Mr. Biggs could be heard saying that he was trying to get in touch with Mr. Jones and wanted to meet up with him that day. The two men apparently never did meet at the Capitol. Mr. Jones, who helped lead a crowd from Mr. Trump’s speech near the White House to the Capitol grounds, attracted serious scrutiny from investigators but was ultimately not charged in the inquiry.

As for Mr. Rehl, Erik Kenerson, a prosecutor, told Judge Kelly that he had lied not only when he took the stand during the trial, but has also continued lying about the proceeding.

Mr. Rehl, he said, conducted multiple interviews from jail, “claiming this court caved to political pressure in declining to dismiss the case.”

Judge Kelly’s decision to impose what is known as a terrorism enhancement on both men’s sentences was one of the most consequential he made on Thursday. The measure can be applied if prosecutors can show that a defendant’s actions were undertaken in an effort to influence “the conduct of government by intimidation and coercion.”

But because Mr. Biggs in particular did not engage in any violence against people, the terrorism enhancement emerged from a charge in which he was found guilty of damaging a government-owned fence in a way that allowed other rioters to surge forward.

While Judge Kelly said the provision was technically applicable, he was less certain — given what Mr. Biggs had actually done — that it fit in a more colloquial sense.

He noted that he had reviewed several cases involving terrorism, most concerning situations where defendants “were training to fight American troops or planning an act like blowing up a large building.” And he expressed skepticism that the Proud Boys had engaged in that kind of behavior on Jan. 6.

Norm Pattis, a lawyer representing both Mr. Biggs and Mr. Rehl, agreed, saying that in most terrorism cases the defendants stand accused of actions like taking hostages or creating biological weapons.

“No serious person in this room will argue that the fence was destroyed with the intent of influencing government,” Mr. Pattis said. “It was a means to an end.”

But Jason McCullough, the lead prosecutor in the case, told Judge Kelly that while the crimes committed by the Proud Boys that day did not “involve mass casualties,” they did involve an attack on Congress — one, he added, that “pushed us to the edge of a constitutional crisis.”

“There’s a reason why we will hold our collective breaths as we approach further elections,” Mr. McCullough said. “We never gave it a second thought before Jan. 6 — none of us.”

Alan Feuer covers extremism and political violence. He joined The Times in 1999. More about Alan Feuer

Zach Montague is based in Washington. He covers breaking news and developments around the district.More about Zach Montague

Leave a Reply